Nice to meet you: Discussion boards in online or hybrid learning models

In my experiments with what I call a BOLD (or Blended Online Learning Model) of instructional design, I’ve come to love the discussion board. I say this reluctantly, because I really hated the discussion board for a long, long time. The discussion board felt like the worst of the online world: full of opinions, dominated by one person, and completely untethered from reality. I thought it was going to be a place where students got lost in terrible functionality and would have to wade through a clunky interface just to post “I’m here” comments. I could not have been more wrong!

In my BOLD learning modality (which includes face to face meetings with students, as well as asynchronous learning experiences) I use discussion boards for three main purposes.

1. I use discussion boards to get students writing, some for the first time in a while. I find that a discussion board conversation can be a good warm up exercise about a week before an assignment is due, mostly because it gets them writing and crafting their thoughts on “paper” at the beginning of the term.

2. I use discussion boards to get students talking, to each other and to me. With the right prompts, a discussion board can be a great place for students to open up, to share their background and their concerns, and to connect with other members of their learning community. Even my most introverted students are more likely to connect with a classmate or two after sharing their “getting to know you” post and I see the benefits of those connections throughout the term. My requests for being on a team with another specific student skyrocket after our “So…What Brings You Here” discussion board assignment and these requests come from students who did not know each other prior to class!

3. I use discussion boards to help students build the critical thinking and reflective practice skills they need to succeed in the course. By challenging students to discuss and reflect upon specific topics using prompts and micro case studies on a discussion board with low stakes and short posting requirements, I can give them a safe space to build the muscles they need to think critically about difficult or challenging topics. By requiring them to both author a post (or thread) and to reply to a post or thread authored by another student, they practice their critique and empathy skills. And perhaps most importantly, I can use this space to evaluate where we are at as a learning community on writing skills, critical thinking skills and even more mechanical issues like citation skills and responding to or following directional prompts in writing.

My BOLD courses have taught me that the discussion board is not the world of trolls and online attendance. Instead, it has become a valuable part of all of my blended online learning delivery work, and I hope you give it a try too.

Published by

AnneMarie Dorland

AnneMarie Dorland is an Assistant Professor in the Bissett School of Business at Mount Royal University, an innovation focused university that offers a different kind of business education to students who want to make a change in our world. Named a Joseph Armand Bombardier Scholar by SSHRC and a member of the University of Calgary’s Teaching Academy, Dorland has been committed to bringing together her background as a graphic designer, brand strategist and qualitative researcher to develop innovative, creative and design-oriented undergraduate learning experiences for the past decade. Through her work as a mentor and facilitator, she has supported undergraduate research and inquiry-based learning for hundreds of students in the classroom and in work integrated learning projects. She maintains a research focus on creativity and creative problem solving practices such as design thinking and her current program of research focuses on design-based problem solving practices and their use in undergraduate student learning outside of the studio space. Dorland has played an integral role in the design and leadership of the inquiry-based and experientially focused UCalgary Global Challenges curriculum, the first of its kind in Canada, and in the development and implementation of undergraduate research support for a U15 Canadian University. A creative practice researcher and contributor to several international publications on the use of design-based problem solving, she is passionate about using the practices of the studio to help students create new and innovative ideas in their marketing, branding and design work. Dorland is a professional member of the International Society for the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning (ISSOTL), the International Association of Business Communicators (IABC), Ethnographic Praxis in Industry (EPIC), the Service Design Network (SDN), the Canadian Communication Association (ACC-CCA), the Canadian Sociological Association (CSA), the Canadian Marketing Association (CMA), Registered Graphic Designers (RGD), Graphic Designers of Canada (GDC) and the Design Management Institute (DMI).

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s